Alan Johnson Reflection




Alan Johnson's article is an interesting delve into each of our roles in bias and discrimination. It scratches the surface of many societal issues, such as racism, classism, sexism, and just broadly, discrimination as a whole. But the whole article (as he himself mentions) is written from the point of view of a white, cishet, male, and as a whole, misses the mark. I myself am white, and male presenting, so we share that, but there are a few key differences. First of all, while he acknowledges that he is coming from a place of privilege, he lacks the inside perspective of someone who has experienced these things. I have a small bit more than him, having experienced homophobia and some classism firsthand, but I will never experience racism or sexism. I can seek to understand them, but it simply is not my place to preach about how we are "all the problem." I do believe that everyone has a part they can play, but these parts are so drastically different, and are unfairly assigned. My life is not by default controversial. I look "normal." I can live my life ignorant of the greater issues around me. Not everyone can say the same. These issues are not vague concepts that some theoretical people experience, they are real issues that many many real people have to deal with regularly. Whether it be explaining sexuality, or fighting to exist in white spaces, there is almost a burden of being "different." I will speak from the experience I do have. I am not straight. When people first discover this, it is a barrage of questions. I have the burden of explaining to people who I am, and not everyone believes that I should be allowed to exist, or at least be allowed to exist at the same level they do. This applies to any minority you can think of. By being "different," we have to fight for our space. White, cishet men don't have to do that. Alan Johnson makes some good points but it comes off as white saviorism and almost as if he is pushing blame. Yes, everyone can make a difference, but not everyone has a choice, whether or not they have to fight.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My life in pictures!

Image
 HBO's "The Gilded Age" Orchestra, which I was a violinist in. My youth orchestra got the highest rating at a festival we attended! Another gig I had, which I can't legally talk about... My sweet cat, Beau!
Read more

Finn Reflection

Image
Patrick J. Finn writes that the way we teach literacy has a different result depending on the student's socioeconomic class. "When rich children get empowering education nothing changes. But when working-class children get empowering education you get literacy with an attitude," which is brilliant. Just as Finn says, educated working class children are often very outspoken about their issues, but are treated much differently. There are brilliant, educated people of every race, class, gender, everything. But the voices that society calls "angry" are always black, or women, or gay, or something. White people argue logically and critically, while everyone else is "hysterical." Literacy with an attitude.
Read more

Delpit Reflection

Image
  Lisa Delpit brings more experiences to the table than Alan Johnson, creating a more grounded experience while reading. She brings anecdotes from her life and from the real world to show us that there is a substantial difference in the education we receive, and to make it worse, almost nobody is doing anything about it. I say almost, because as Delpit says, white people are listening, but not hearing . I can't claim to be an exception to this, but I can strive to hear. What I will claim is that while teaching, I find that tuning into the people themselves, to their experiences, yields the best results. Each student should be treated differently, given what they need. Common core makes this difficult, as its goal is to standardize everything. This makes it very difficult to hear  what students need. Sure, I understand that this student's reading and writing levels are below average, but with common core, the goal is no longer education, it is to pass a test. These things are n...
Read more